Cathedral is my clothes horse, so far as my small army of alts is considered. Here’s what she’s wearing at the moment.
The farther we get from Cataclysm, Pauldrons of Edward the Odd are going to become harder and harder to find. If they aren’t currently available on your Auction House, the clone Burden of Morality drops from Chimaeron in Blackwing Descent. Meanwhile, Paladins with a Mantle of the Forlorn Conqueror token can purchase Reinforced Sapphirium Mantle from the Legacy Justice Quartermaster.
For a slightly different look, consider the Blinding Girdle of Truth (purchased from the Valor Quartermaster for 1,650 JP) instead.